Story: Rumination part 1
Author: WalkingMaelstrom
And on that note, we leave Torture-Device's writing and Lord Vect, as I turn to the next part in the "epic saga" of Rivals Til Death, hammered out by WalkingMaelstrom.
I have to say, after those chapters of mangled English, I am almost glad to see the writing of WalkingMaelstrom. Almost. Because with his return to the keyboard of command, it means we return to overly-flowery language, walls of text and Naruto referencing out of the ass.
"The nerve of these naysayers!" He vented under his breath, intentionally for those within a small radius to hear. "Brutalizing and callously putting all to the torch while striding so cocksure amidst our sacred halls. I feel as if a taint of arrogance had just passed through, that 'construct' of a human being, black bile and blood oozing out like some childhood parlor trick. And the gall he possesses to question me, question us!"
Space Marines have a high-strung way of speaking (because they have little interaction with normal humans), but they are still soldiers, yet not soldiers who would use the word "cocksure", so this just comes off as amazingly silly. This entire paragraph so wonderfully sums up why I dislike WalkingMaelstrom's writing so much. He seems to know where the Space Marines are coming from, but doesn't quite grasp what makes them what they are. Like psycho-indoctrination, which removes a Space Marine's memories of his childhood. Apparently Cailean can still remember his, further proof that he's a Gary-Stu (as if that was needed), seeing as this little fact slipped by the Chief Librarian completely.
This is swiftly followed by a half-page long paragraph describing the persona and personal history of Chapter Master Quintus. The term "info dump" has never felt more appropriate. And WalkingMaelstrom seems to like the words "nettlesome" and "vitriolic", seeing as these words reappear very often in his parts.
We are also treated to this piece of homoerotica:
Upon arrival back to the chapter's battle barge, Quintus also noticed the air of longing from Brother-Sergeant Seo, as if he had missed out on a great trial to prove himself.
WalkingMaelstrom seems to also have picked up on the head-scratchingly strange paragraphing that Torture-Device was prone to, and it does nothing for my reading experience.
Dinotus is thus ordered by Quintus to collect the entire Librarium and get to do what Librarians do best: study and find information, in this case deeper knowledge about Lady Tina Fey and the Flawless Host warband. You would think they had already done this, mind. Cailean is not allowed to join them, however. He is to spend his time meditating and resting. I can partly agree with this course of action, but it still baffles me that Cailean has not received any kind of punishment for outright murdering important prisoners?
It is good to know that Dinotus at least recognises that Cailean has the mind of a twelve-year-old:
Well, apart from claiming it is a source of strength, then. It is not. Cailean is an immature brat, you just said it yourself, Dinotus! How is this a source of strength? Never explained."Two-hundred and fifty years running and he is still a young one in mind, my good friend. That is a testament to his strength."
The scene then shifts to Seo's squad with Apothecary Haruch, Verdius (still no consensus reached on whether this is how his name is spelled) and the new man: Lope Angelico, being bitter over Cailean being rebuked by a Lord Inquisitor for his unorthodox manner. The scene is muted, and some parts even approach good writing, but it is all for naught, as it feels jumbled in a temporal way. They are talking about something which, as far as I can tell, happened long ago, but they make it sound like it happened last week. And although Lope has an amazingly silly name and is a mole, he brings some sense to the scene by bluntly asking:
"This defense for a man who nearly broke your jaw for merely questioning the brutal killing of two suspects?"
But people are not allowed to make sense in this series, seeing as Space Marines act like sullen and petulant children more often than not here. Verdius, the dumb fuck, rises to the obvious bait, only to be verbally slapped around by Sergreant Seo, who then proceeds to reprimand Lope as well, in the most contrived manner possible:
"The Epistolary and I have been friends since our youths, and if you are looking for a physical retaliation to continued verbal jabs, then you'll get them from me."
Am I the only one getting the feeling that WalkingMaelstrom seems to think Space Marine squads work like squads of ninjas in Naruto? Wait... don't tell me that... No! NO! Lope Angelico is supposed to be Sai with facial hair! FUCK!
![]() |
Next he'll be asking to see your penis, Cailean. |
The scene peters out with Apothecary Haruch saying he will go study to find out more about the Sick Six, but not before some heavy-handed foreshadowing is dropped on poor Lope's shoulders in that Cailean has a terrible temper and he should be careful about that. THUMP! That was the sound of a plot-point dropping.
Minutes that felt like hours passed.
This is everything in that paragraph. Why it is there, fuck knows, like so many other things in this series. Those minutes were apparently some further dialogue between Seo and his squad, with Verdius background actually being delivered to us in an info-dump that felt pertinent, revealing his relationship with Cailean and why he's fine with being literally slapped around by the Epistolary. It's not good, mind you, but at least it shows us some characterization.
We then get a flashback, completely in italics, from nowhere, really. In it we learn of Seo's getting to know Cailean as young initiates to the chapter. We also learn that initates don't get much food, as their muscles are thin (strange, considering the massive amounts of energy needed to grow a human into a Space Marine) and that psykers are tolerated but shunned. Young Cailean has a codicier handler to watch over him, but it is still strange that he is allowed to take his puny meal together with the other boys.
Another problem is the following:
What children talk like this?"I don't really care. Would it not benefit us to know each other? Back where I came from, life and death depended upon your allies."
With the words "So long ago." we switch then from the Imperial Paladins to go back in a flash to the Sick Six on board their pink dildo ship. There, Zekkel is looking for Torturer, who it would seem is off sulking, again! He comes across Malexis, and it is obvious the Techmarine cum Apothercary doesn't care much for the dark apostle. Holy shit! Is this...? Yes, character interaction and development!
It is not much, but hey, I take what I can get!
Malexis agrees to help Zekkel find Torturer and get him in better spirits.
Malexis agrees to help Zekkel find Torturer and get him in better spirits.
Torturer is sitting in meditation, alone, thinking of how to get at Cailean, about whom Torturer has this reflection:
And even then, the Librarian fought like a man possessed.
THUMP! That was the sound of another plot-point. And further foreshadowing.
Torturer's meditation chambers are however befitting a slave to She Who Thirsts, as it is full of noise and smells, which makes this line even more puzzling than it should be:
Then came the distinct sound of blades emerging.
Torturer at first thinks it is the Wych Aeseryth, but it is not. It is a human female, who seems very eager to ride some Astartes cock, seeing as she is sending out the signals "I am hornier than a mountain goat, do me now!". Her name is Cath. Though, instead of sex, Torturer launches into a flashback of how his warband came in possession of this woman.
And that is just the beginning of the flashback.Cath…lovely, seductive, and sensually deadly Cath. She was once an able and proudly fighting PDF sergeant upon her home world and a rare sight of beauty amongst her peers. Her company was one of the toughest out there and she had garnered accolades for her efforts in putting down insurrections in the past. However, as years went by since she was inducted as a teenager, her thoughts and experiences with the haughty nobles of the Imperium had horrendously soured her demeanor. Once while putting down a rumored Dark Mechanicus cult that had unleashed daemonic machinery, the nobles there had the gall to not only exploit the refugees but also take possession of everything once it was brutally put down. Her own platoon sergeant, a brusque and burly woman whom she swore was more a man, would also beat her regularly should she slip at all. As years passed she got sick of it all. Dark thoughts and whispers of the once-suppressed emotions infiltrated her soul. She wanted out, but she knew it'd mean certain death. She needed a spark.Torturer was that spark.
Cath is, apart from being author-fellatio in a tin, a Mary-Sue, with a past of having trouble with the Imperial nobility, something that is becoming a bit of a theme in these stories: having issues with authority, as if the authors of it have the minds of teenagers and are angry at their parents and this is some strange way of getting back at them.
Apparently Cath eventually rebelled against the Imperium as Torturer's warband raided her home world, standing in front of him and offering her the dead corpse of her sergeant for him to violate six ways from Sunday. Delightful though this is, it would seem Torturer decided to do this in the middle of a skirmish to take a garrison, and Cath just stood there dumbly watching him raping the corpse. And neither of them were shot by those still loyal?
The flashback ends and we're back in the present.
Cath seems to have the mind of an eight-year-old, though, so some damage must've been done to her brain during the stasis that mortals are kept in for no apparent reason on the Engine of Obscenity.
"It is some lapdog Astartes, isn't it? Please tell me of him! I'll kill him myself for you, Lord! He is likely haughty and blind with pride! He could be easy prey for me!"
Her enthusiasm is almost infectuous. Sadly, so is her stupidity. Torturer realizes this and takes her out of that mindset by describing what Cailean should've done with him in the very first part of this series, if I may say so myself.
We're also reminded that the Shadowbone (the thought of that hurts my head) still exists, and Cath seems to think that Slaaneshii servants are noble. Torturer is smart enough to not agree with this unspeakably naïve thinking, to his credit.
The scene ends with Torturer suggesting meditation in the noisy, smelly, blood dripping halls, but Cath has other ideas as she undresses and sits on his lap.
End scene, thank the Muses.
But this part is far from done, Lords and Ladies! Did you think your suffering was over? No, far from.
Because we have to see what happened to Inquisitor Tina Fey. Remember where we left her? Yeah, so we pick up the next scene with her in Inquisitorial captivity.
She hasn't got much to do, so we get a recap of the events of two parts hence. Unnecessary as far as I'm concerned because there is no way in hell I would ever forget that. But it seems that WalkingMaelstrom is under the misconception that good writing means reiterating the same thing over and over, hammering it into people's heads like a stubborn nail. This gets even weirder when you consider the fact that both Torture-Device and WalkingMaelstrom are very reticent with words and information as soon as it means something that could actually advance the readers' knowledge of what the flying fuck in going on.
To put it another way: they pad out parts that don't need any padding, and leave the reader floundering for knowledge in parts that could be expanded upon. The message it sends is that our two authors have no idea where this story is going, have no over-arching plot and literally just make things up as they go along.
So we get paragraphs like this:
Nevermind the awful fact that nearly every single sentence starts with the word "she".
Those words chilled her to the bone, unable to fully accept that it was she who said that to that fiend. She knew it. She had capitulated. She resigned herself to her base fears. She went along with Torturer's desires in the fear of becoming a mutilated plaything with makeshift orifices to have one's way with. She saw the utter excitement in the warped Techmarine's face displaying his handiwork. The fear paralyzed her too much. She wanted to vomit the second she saw the Noise Raptor grin from ear to ear with jagged teeth manifested by the mask.
Oh for such poetry in this.
Inquisitor Tina cares for her comrades too, wondering what has happened to them. But most of all, she is worried about Moerchen.
Tears were pressing themselves to leave her eyes upon the possibilities of just what the psyker did to the daemon and to the chaplain. The likelihood of possession and surviving such ordeals, especially against Space Marines, was quite slim. She wanted to cling to hope though, but hope was becoming an ever-snapping rope that she dangled off of. Every time she tried to hold, each possibility was like a small fiber snapping. She knew her ultimate fate was soon to be determined.
What the fuck is an "ever-snapping rope"?
As Lady Tina is dragged to another round of questioning, she conveniently passes Lieutenant Xin, who's being led back to her cell, and the two are allowed to talk, as it take a while for the guards to whack Xin over the head to shut up, but Inquisitor Tina learns that Moerchen is still alive, and some about the Eldar involved.
Tina strode forward. In the matter of less than a minute, a broken and weary woman had suddenly found confidence. The one man that mattered more to her save for the Emperor Himself lives. She had no reason to fear now, for hope had returned, as he would one day to her embrace.With a heavy rush of faith restored, she no longer feared what lied ahead. For as long as he lived, so would she.
See, Lord Vect and I weren't lying when we said that every single woman
in this story is there solely to be little satellites around the beefcake men, their entire lives revolving around the males.
Why? Because they are women. This has gone beyond the sexism of manga
such as Naruto and into a completely different country of misogyny. My guess: Afghanistan before the Talibans were driven out.
We then switch scenes to Cailean, our last stop for this part. He is sitting in his private chambers, thinking about what has just happened. And one of those thoughts is that a chapter master's orders apparently are "wishes" that can be brokered. How are these people soldiers again?
Cailean goes into meditation, as ordered, and in his recollection of events, he starts having conversations with... something... in his head.
"They plot against you…they fear your power.""What?!?""You are strong, very strong. You possess great power and it is continuously held back! Look towards your ranks for your demise! You could have easily destroyed Torturer and his pathetic allies, yet you did nothing and watched Ashur be butchered. Where is his helmet, Cailean? Where is his helmet to lay to rest with his bones? Did it become lost?""No…""Oh yes…yessssssss. You must find that traitor. You must rip his mask off and feed it to the empty socket he'd call a mouth. You must pluck his eyes out and stick them upon the spikes of his armor! Rip his comrades in half! Release your anger upon them!""What…what is this?!?"
I call daemon.
"KILL! BURN THEIR BODIES TO ASH, CAILEAN! YOU HOLD YOURSELF BACK WHEN YOU CAN DO SO MUCH MORE!"
Yeah, definitely daemonic. My guess would be Khornate, but that does not sit well with Cailean being a psyker. And the hysterical ALL CAPS is back. Nearly a chapter with only the odd burst and here we go again. Some people never learn.
The screaming reached the very center of his cortex, making him grasp his head in agony. "DESTROY THEM ALL! YOU MUST DO THIS AND KILL THE TRAITOR! COAT YOURSELF IN HIS BLOOD AND HANG HIS HEAD FOR YOUR COMRADES TO SEE! THE EMPEROR DEMANDS IT OF YOU, CAILEAN! DO IT!""Nnnnnnnahhhhhhhhhhh!" He screamed at the top of his lungs. The voices continued to rant, scream, beckon, and wail. When would it end? "Stop! Stop thinking this way, Cailean!" He screamed to himself to form some discipline, fighting every square inch of his personal temptations. His anger had manifested itself into his dreams and for the first time in a while he was perturbed.
Perturbed? Is that all you are? I know Space Marines know no fear, but really now? Cailean is learned enough to be able to note potential daemonic possession, it is what he has been trained to be on the lookout for in new recruits, has he not? Why the fuck doesn't he recognize the taint within himself then? Sheer fucking inability? Or is he just that dumb?
Cailean's waking nightmare is interrupted by a woman's voice, obviously his mother. He gets up, covered in blood from seemingly nowhere, and walks over to a potted plant on his desk, stroking the glass container it is under lovingly, never mind that if it was hermetically sealed, the plant would've died long ago.
![]() |
Can't possibly be a reference to any movie can it? |
"Dear Emperor…what's…what's happening…to me?"
You're possessed, you dumb fuck.
And with Cailean sitting down in prayer, part 1 of Rumination ends.
----------
Dark Muses alive is this a dull, fucking part!
You'd think that after the last part, despite the headscratchingly contrived manner in which the so-called Shadowbone was created, at least we had a semblance of a plot line started. I don't care if it was 10 parts into a 30+ part series of fanfics and that it is a thinly veiled attempt to cover this being anything but a galactic dick-waving competition. It was a plot, or at least resembled something akin to a plot.
The title Rumination is apt, but not in the sense "inner reflections", which I think is what WalkingMaelstrom aimed for. It fits in the sense "mastication done by cows". Because what little we had in terms of plot grinds to a halt, as we are still introduced to new characters, without the previous ones having been that well defined to begin with. This will only end in complete and utter confusion, as if that was not immediately obvious.
Even worse is that WalkingMaelstrom continues to reference Naruto, shoehorning the manga into the 40k universe. There's Lope, who is the obvious Sai of Cailean's group, and Cailean has gotten even closer to Naruto himself, in that he now seems to sport something akin to the Kyuubi/Nine-tails demon inside him. Seriously, what the fuck is up with that? And Torturer reminds me more and more of Orochimaru. Apart from the black hair of the manga character, they look very much alike, don't they?
Esteemed nobles of the Commorragh book club, this has gone beyond being plain awful fan-fiction (there is a lot of that) to being fascinating. It is like a traffic accident happening before your eyes, you just can't look away. You keep watching because some sick, twisted part of you wants to know what depths these two manchildren will plumb next.
With that, I leave you once again to the tender mercies of Lord Vect. I hope he appreciates that he gets the shorter half of a part that could as well have been named "Mastication".
//L//